A relevance - theoret ic account of metarepresentative uses in conditionals *
نویسنده
چکیده
The purpose of this paper is to give a relevance-theoretic account of certain 'non-basic' indicative conditionals. There has been a claim (e.g. Grice 1989) that natural language if is semantically identical with material implication in logic. This approach runs into some problems, one of which is that some natural-language conditionals do not appear to involve the required truth-functional relation between antecedent and consequent. I attempt to show that the relevance-theoretic notions of metarepresentation and pragmatic enrichment (Carston 1988, Wilson and Sperber 1992) allow us to preserve the view that if is equivalent to material implication.
منابع مشابه
A reason maintenance perspective on relevant Ramsey conditionals
This paper presents a Ramsey account of conditionals within the framework of an implemented reason maintenance system. The reason maintenance system is built on top of a deductive reasoning engine based on relevance logic. Thus, the account of conditionals provided is not susceptible to the fallacies of relevance. In addition, it is shown that independently motivated requirements on practical r...
متن کاملA Ranking-Theoretic Approach to Conditionals
Conditionals somehow express conditional beliefs. However, conditional belief is a bi-propositional attitude that is generally not truth-evaluable, in contrast to unconditional belief. Therefore, this article opts for an expressivistic semantics for conditionals, grounds this semantics in the arguably most adequate account of conditional belief, that is, ranking theory, and dismisses probabilit...
متن کاملClinical Relevance of Faecal Calprotectin Level in Infantile Colic: A Cross-sectional Survey
Background: There is limited knowledge on the potential applicability of fecal calprotectin (f-CP) as an inflammatory screening parameter in infantile colic (IC). This study aimed to evaluate f-CP in neonates with IC as a useful diagnostic indicator regarding this condition. Methods: The present study was conducted on 100 cases, including 50 newborns with IC and 50 non-colicky neonates. The dia...
متن کاملConditionals and Action Logics
The logic of conditionals (and, especially, of subjunctive or counterfactual conditionals) is a long-standing problem for the theory of common sense reasoning and philosophical logic. In this paper, I explore commonalities between the logical accounts of the conditional involving “closeness” relations over possible worlds and work in the logic of action and change that attempts to characterize ...
متن کامل16 Conditionals RAJESH BHATT AND ROUMYANA PANCHEVA
1 Introduction 2 Defining conditionals 2.1 What is a conditional? 2.2 The marking of conditionals 3 Structural issues 3.1 The position of merger of the if-clause 3.1.1 If-clauses as adverbial clauses 3.1.2 Height of attachment 3.1.3 A source for sentence-initial if-clauses 3.2 Clause-internal syntax of the if-clause 3.2.1 The location of if 3.2.2 The conditional–interrogative link 3.2.3 The abs...
متن کامل